After finishing Ian Cameron Esslemont's sixth Malazan-related novel, Assail, I felt as though I had read almost the same book, with almost the same characters, with almost the same progression of scenes and action. It was all-too-familiar reading an account of how characters/groups covered in Esslemont's previous novels (the Crimson Guard, Kyle, the various Elder Races and their epoch-spanning conflicts) work their way from an initial mystery (just what is transpiring on the dangerous, isolated continent of Assail; is there truly a treasure trove to be mountain in the mountains to the north; what is causing the Jaghut-created ice fields to melt; what has happened to the missing T'lan Imass tribes) through encounters along the way until all meet together in the end. If this does not sound interesting, it is perhaps less due to the macro plot developments and more because of a lack of differentiation in the smaller details.
On the surface, the various plots would be entertaining in isolation. Seeing the fruition of Kyle's character arc is something that did hold promise before I read the book. The same goes for discovering just what was transpiring at Assail or the reason behind the seeming age-defying Crimson Guard, as over the course of the previous fifteen Malazan books, Esslemont and Steven Erikson had dropped enough hints as to make their resolutions tantalizing for those readers who had read all of the volumes. Yet there were times in the past where certain resolutions did not carry the punch that readers might have anticipated. For every The Crippled God finale, there was the revelation behind Darujistan's Tyrants that fell a little flat. Esslemont's novels especially have been hit-or-miss, with the relative quality of Return of the Crimson Guard or Blood and Bone being balanced by the unevenness of Night of Knives or Orb Sceptre Throne. Unfortunately, Assail is among the weaker of Esslemont's novels, not so much because of dampened expectations but because of certain redundancies in his storytelling.
The story opens, as do most Malazan books, with a prologue that transpires tens of thousands of years before the narrative present. This itself is not a problem, but when the prologue progression follows so closely to that of Memories of Ice that it is easy to guess what a major revelation will be late in the novel, this lessens the impact of the scene. This important subplot is also hampered in its effectiveness by a lack of development of the conflicts between the living Imass Bonecaster Silverfox and the returning "lost" Imass tribes that still seek their eternal war against the Jaghut. There is little "why" explored, as Esslemont too quickly moves onto a chase narrative for these scenes.
Assail also suffers from other half-baked narrative elements. The (re)introduction of a major character is handled rather poorly here. His momentary amnesia is too closely related to that of another returning character in a previous Esslemont novel that it felt as though entire lines could have been transposed from one character/novel to another and little would have been confusing or out of place. This was just sheer lazy writing, as the plot and dialogue should have been better differentiated in order to escape the feeling of narrative deja vu.
And yet despite all of these shortcomings, the actual concluding story almost made up for it all. While the convergence plot device is rather passé this far into the combined Malazan series, the conclusions promise a new chapter in this world. In addition, there are certainly enough open threads for both Erikson and Esslemont to explore more of this setting and the new developments revealed in the final two chapters. Certainly Assail is not the end of Esslemont's contributions, despite long-standing claims (the inside flap even perpetuates it) that it would be the conclusion of Esslemont's side-series (Esslemont has signed for three more Malazan-based books). Hopefully Esslemont will not repeat the mistakes of this pedestrian novel and will try to craft something approaching an original narrative progression for his next book. As it stands, Assail is one of the two weakest novels in the entire Malazan sequence.