The OF Blog

Saturday, June 04, 2011

Fifty Books That Dwell In My Thoughts

Back in May 2006, I posted a list of 50 personal favorites.  Without looking at that list until my work was done, I went through my bookshelves and wrote down the titles of 50 works whose names made me think the fondest (or most disturbing, in some cases) of thoughts.  There is some overlap with the 2006 list, but not as much as I would have suspected.  The titles are listed in the order that I wrote them down and are not necessarily a ranking:

1.  Vladimir Nabokov, Ada

2.  Gene Wolfe, The Book of the New Sun (omnibus)


3.  Umberto Eco, The Name of the Rose

4.  Ursula Le Guin, The Dispossessed

5.  Norman Mailer, The Executioner's Song

6.  John Steinbeck, The Grapes of Wrath

7.  Cormac McCarthy, Blood Meridian

8.  Gabriel García Márquez, Cien años de soledad

9.  Roberto Bolaño, 2666

10.  Johann Wolfgang von Goethe, Faust (both parts)

11.  Antoine de Saint-Exupéry, Le Petit Prince

12.  Karen Tei Yamashita, I Hotel

13.  Téa Obreht, The Tiger's Wife

14.  M. John Harrison, The Course of the Heart

15.  Angela Carter, Nights at the Circus

16.  Salvador Plascencia, The People of Paper

17.  Shirley Jackson, The Haunting of Hill House

18.  Michael Cisco, The Narrator

19.  Italo Calvino, Invisible Cities

20.  John Crowley, Ægypt Cycle (series)

21.  Milorad Pavić, Landscape Painted With Tea

22.  Zoran Živković, Escher's Loops

23.  Thomas Liggoti, The Nightmare Factory

24.  Flannery O'Connor, Collected Works (Library of America edition)

25.  William Faulkner, The Sound and the Fury

26.  Thomas Wolfe, You Can't Go Home Again

27.  David Foster Wallace, Infinite Jest

28.  Harper Lee, To Kill a Mockingbird

29.  Herman Melville, Moby Dick

30.  Sadegh Hedayat, The Blind Owl

31.  Mark Danielewski, House of Leaves

32.  John Keats, Poems 


33.  Jorge Luis Borges, El Aleph  


34.  Thomas Pynchon, Gravity's Rainbow 

35.  Ben Okri, The Famished Road 


36.  Henry David Thoreau, Walden  

37.  Edward Whittemore, Jerusalem Quartet (series)


38.  T.S. Eliot, The Wasteland 

39.  Franz Kafka, The Trial 


40.  Julio Cortázar, Rayuela (Hopscotch) 

41.  José Saramago, Blindness 


42.  Ludovico Ariosto, Orlando Furioso 

43.  Art Spiegelman, Maus 


44.  Milan Kundera, The Unbearable Lightness of Being 

45.  Virginia Woolf, To the Lighthouse 


46.  James Joyce, Ulysses 

47.  Jeff VanderMeer, Shriek:  An Afterword 


48.  J.G. Ballard, The Complete Stories of J.G. Ballard 

49.  Thomas Mann, The Magic Mountain 


50.  Dino Buzzati, The Tartar Steppe 


Which ones of these have you read?  Any you want to know more about, whether it be in the form of a full review or a short comment?  Feel free to try and discern patterns here, if that is what you enjoy doing.

Thursday, June 02, 2011

The Critic as a Reader: Reactions to Others' Recent Reviews

Even though I receive a lot (well, used to, until eight months ago) of review copies, I still read a lot of reviews for a variety of reasons.  Sometimes, I want information about a particular work, while other times I stumble across a new work due to a serendipitous find in a magazine like The New Yorker.  I try to approach each review differently, gauging its value based on the work in question and how the reviewer's thoughts are developed.

I thought I might illustrate this by writing an extended version of typical reactions to a few reviews that I've seen online or in magazine.  I'll link to the online reviews and quote one or more snippets before providing a brief commentary on my reactions.  Hopefully, this exercise will help me as a reviewer, as I do sometimes forget when writing a review that what I write might not satisfy those readers like myself.  Anyways, here goes:

The Speculative Scotsman, review of Elspeth Cooper's Songs of the Earth 

For the most part, I enjoy reading Niall Alexander's reviews, even though they are more colloquial than my typical reading fare.  He often has cogent points to make, so it was with some disappointment that I read this review (he also has a two-part interview with the author that he's posting this week, so that might have affected things).  Below is an excerpt that led to my eyebrows being raised:

Well. There's a lot about Songs of the Earth you'll find familiar if you've kept up with the genre since The Name of the Wind redefined success and our expectations thereof in 2007. Fantasy tropes old and new proliferate, in fact, from the very first: "The magic was breaking free again," the telling of this tale begins. "Its music sang along Gair's nerves as if they were harp-strings, a promise of power thrumming through his fingers. All he had to do was embrace it, if he dared." (p.5)

This paragraph says so little with so many words.  "since The Name of the Wind [Patrick Rothfuss' debut novel] redefined success and our expectations thereof in 2007?"  The comparative approach rings hollow, since there's really nothing substantive behind "fantasy tropes old and new proliferate" other than it sounding nice, trite, and palatable for those who make their book buying decisions based on how closely Book X mimics successful elements of Book Y.   Niall usually is a more astute reviewer, but here in this review he rarely dips beyond platitudes to discuss a debut novel that sounds as though it is a generic genre work due to a lack of engagement with the story itself.  Sure, it is "spoiler free," but one of the problems of making a review so devoid of specific references to the actual story is that the review feels bland and lacking of any real exploration of the text itself to say whether or not it itself is worthy of consideration.  Making passing references to a work without explicating those apparent connections serves little good, especially when the reader (such as myself) had only a lukewarm reaction to works such as Rothfuss'.

The Mad Hatter's Bookshelf & Book Review, review of Genevieve Valentine's Mechanique:  A Tale of the Circus Tresaulti 

I don't read Michael's reviews as much as I do Niall's, so I don't have as much ground for comparison.  I have noticed that he tends to be effusive in his praise and that his reviews are oriented more toward the "fan" side of viewing book reviews as a means of recommending works to others.  There is nothing wrong with that approach, other than certain readers (and I often am among them, but not exclusively) might not benefit much from it.

In this particular review, Michael does provide at least some basis in his introduction for describing the subtype of book Valentine's book may fall under.  However, my eyes glazed a bit when I saw blurbish descriptors like "unforgettable" and "haunt your dreams" appearing alongside "pacing" and "unlikeable characters."  It felt a bit more like a reworded press release (with the dubious addition of the "unlikeable characters") in places because while there is the illusion of analysis, the whole felt more like a breezy commentary that tries to avoid any contentious discussion of the book's "meat."  I am intrigued by this book, but not because I see "Fans of early Mieville and VanderMeer will fall in love," but rather because there might be something worthwhile about this book that just isn't being discussed here.  Again, this is not the type of review aimed at readers such as myself and I would readily admit that it serves its purpose well for those readers who want a new title to consider without having much more than the review equivalent of a back cover blurb.


Dazed Rambling, review of Téa Obreht's The Tiger's Wife  

I also enjoy reading reviews of books I've already read (and sometimes reviewed), just to see if others like what I liked or if they have a different slant than I did on the prose, characterizations, theme, and plot.  James Oliver often is a bit more introspective in his reviews than what I encounter from several other online reviewers and I found it interesting to see how closely his take on Obreht's debut novel dovetails with my own.  Of particular interest was this excerpt:


Mostly, we learn about war. It runs in the background, a perpetual nightmare that inspires a range of reactions from the surreal to the horrific. People sit in cafes, sipping coffee and chatting as the war drops bombs around them. Everything breaks down as people stop caring—why do this or that when there is a war on? A village is whipped into paranoid superstition, the tiger lurking in the hills as dreadful as the war lurking on the horizon. The tiger is present though, something real and tangible that they can focus on if only to forget about the war coming for their out of the way mountain home. The Tiger’s Wife is tinged with war that has seeped into the lands, villages, and cities that the characters and stories inhabit. In the midst of the horror that it brings, we see the bits of wonder—the strange behavior that comes to the forefront and the strange little events that become the stories that we keep to ourselves. 
There is more content in this one paragraph than in the two previous reviews combined.  If anything, I think James discusses the war/tiger connection better than I did in my review.  It is a good interpretation of what is happening around and behind the stories highlighted in the novel and I think it is an effective review because it provides more for the reader to consider without analyzing every last iota of information available.


Empty Your Heart of Its Mortal Dream, review "The American Dream in 1969:  Two Films of the American New Wave" 

Paul Charles Smith is one of the best reviewers I've discovered in the past year.  Paul and I have collaborated on several group reviews with Jeff VanderMeer over the past eight months and I believe he offers some approaches to reviewing that could help myself be a better critic.  Paul's reviews are more "formal" in the sense that they often engage more with particular critical theory elements, but what makes his reviews interesting is that whether or not I am familiar with the medium and/or work(s) being reviewed, he manages to balance erudite commentary with clear, limpid prose.

In the film’s most memorable scene, after arriving in New Orleans and visiting a brothel George talked about, Billy and Wyatt take LSD (given to them earlier by the hitchhiker) with two of the prostitutes and find themselves in a graveyard. Utilizing experimental techniques to emulate a bad trip, the scene blends overexposure, sound overdubs, spliced imaging in conjunction with elliptical cutting, and perhaps the most unsettling, Hopper’s direction that Fonda should talk to the statue of the Madonna as if it were his mother who had abandoned him as a child. Shortly afterwards, Wyatt admits to Billy that they have “blew it”, as despite having money, they are unable to attain the freedom as an almost transcendent experience, as they desire. The film’s final shot, the burning wrecking of Wyatt’s motorcycle (seen earlier in a flash forward) stands as a reminder that what you hope for is often unattainable.
Although I am not much of a cinema watcher, I found myself wanting to see Easy Rider in whole due to Paul's exploration of the cinematic techniques employed within the film.  Instead of giving away information, his treatment of the film's substantive elements makes it more intriguing to me because it is obvious there is something present in the film that merits attention.  These are the sorts of reviews, if the story justifies such treatment, that can sway a lot of noncommittal readers (and viewers) such as myself because the review makes it obvious that the work at hand as a depth that warrants discussion and further exploration on the part of the reader/viewer.

Matthew Cheney, Strange Horizons review of Gary K. Wolfe's Essays on Fantastic Literature

I've said before on several occasions that Matt Cheney has been an influence on how I approach reviewing and why I even have a blog in the first place.  Reading this review only solidifies my high esteem for his approach to reviewing and it reminds me of how sketchy and incomplete my own reviews often are in comparison to his thoughtful, cogent analyses of a variety of genres and authors.

One thing that struck me in this particular review (there are too many to comment at length here) is this passage, which underscores a key shift in his own interpretation of the essay collection and its value to other readers:

Wesleyan University Press has published some of the best literary criticism of science fiction in recent decades—the nonfiction of Samuel R. Delany, Justine Larbalestier's The Battle of the Sexes in Science Fiction (2002), Carl Freedman's Critical Theory and Science Fiction (200), John Reider's Colonialism and the Emergence of Science Fiction (2008), Farah Mendlesohn's anthology On Joanna Russ (2009), Istvan Csicsery-Ronay's The Seven Beauties of Science Fiction (2008)—and so when I began reading Evaporating Genres, I assumed it was part of this lineage. A third of the way through Wolfe's book, I found myself terribly frustrated, but I struggled to identify the cause. Wolfe's writing was supple and elegant, his knowledge of science fiction's history impressive, his ideas sane and reasonable. Yet reservations nagged at me; at the end of every chapter I thought, "Is that it?" and, worse, one observation after another made me ask, "So what?" without gaining a satisfying reply from the sentences that followed. Eventually, I wondered what the best audience for Evaporating Genres might be, and it was then I realized I was applying the wrong template of expectations to the text. This was my failure, not the book's.

The ideal reader of Evaporating Genres, in my mind, is someone who has either just begun to explore the wonders and possibilities of science fiction, or someone who needs to be convinced that science fiction can be something other than formulaic pulp stories. This is simply the best book I've ever encountered for such readers. At the same time, though, because Wolfe is so well read in the field of SF, the book provides even very experienced readers with fascinating and insightful connections between texts.

Too often reviewers (and I am guilty of this as well) make the mistake of considering a work solely based on their own personal reactions.  Seldom do we critics take a moment to consider the work from the vantage point of various possible "ideal readers," to test whether or not that book's flaws and shortcomings might be due more to its goals differing from the reviewer's desires than to any uniform deviation from form and quality.  Matt's admission here allows the reader to consider Wolfe's essay collection from multiple perspectives, those related to what baggage the reader/reviewer might be bringing to the table and those concerned with readers considering an unfamiliar genre.  In this regard, his review is successful because it combines a personal reflection on the story with a look at how the work might be of interest or value to readers who might not share Matt's views on the subjects presented within Wolfe's book.

What which of these disparate reviews do for me is make me think in turn about how I approach the craft of reviewing.  I have noticed recently that my own reviews have declined in length and in quality.  I am not saying as much and I seem to be content with utilizing the form of critique without really delving into the substantive elements that such techniques enable the critic to perform the necessary textual vivisection.  Reading these reviews, as well as previous ones on sites such as Eve's Alexandria or Asking the Wrong Questions, do make me think a bit more about why I read and what I enjoy as a reader.  Hopefully, this reflective essay will lead to better reviews from me in the near future.  There are, after all, more things in heaven and earth than are dreamt of in my philosophy.

Wednesday, June 01, 2011

A sample of what I'm reading from Lynd Ward, Gods' Man








Based on these opening images, would you want to "read" more?

New and Used Book Porn for June


Today has been a rather good day.  Got several things taken care of, including a doctor's appointment, so I enjoyed a beautifully warm day (it is still above 90 at a little past 7 PM here).  Part of the day, I spent buying used books, but I also received some new books recently, including the Library of America edition of woodcut artist Lynd Ward's 1920s-1930s wordless graphic novels, pictured above.  Almost 2/3 into the first volume and those who enjoy German impressionists will enjoy Ward's stories, as he spent some time in Weimar Germany studying.  More on Ward shortly.  Also have some used books pictured above, all but one in French or Spanish.


In a poetic frame of mind and after I read a positive review in a recent issue of The New Yorker, I went ahead and purchased The Essential Tagore, which samples from India's first Nobel Prize-winning author.  Was lucky to find the Easton Press of Dickens'  David Copperfield for only $25; it often goes for double that for the very good condition in which I found it. 


Southern Boy can survive...or he can also read more about his cultural heritage.  Very curious about Miller's influences and the other books pictured above will be read and possibly reviewed in the not-so-distant future.


Still reading Cormac McCarthy's earlier, Southern novels and have added one of James Agee's to it.  Curious about the two Spanish-language works as well.

Not too bad of a haul over the past couple of weeks, even if only one of the books pictured here was a review copy (I rarely receive them these days, which is fine by me, although I will occasionally picture the ones I do receive and even review them).  Any of these appeal to you?

So I participated in a group interview of Scott Bakker recently

It just went live at Pat's blog.  Five of the questions I asked.  Can you identify which ones those are from the ones that Adam and Pat wrote?

Tuesday, May 31, 2011

A double dog-dare challenge to readers here

One of the joys in life is enjoying something that may or may not be all that wondrous to share with others.  For many, that joy might be reading a poem or three.  So here's a challenge for readers here:  Copy/paste a favorite poem of yours (language doesn't matter; I'll actually enjoy reading some in languages I know to some degree) in the comments.  Let others discover something that you find to contain some essential element.  Here's one for you:

Theodore Roethke, "The Waking"

I wake to sleep, and take my waking slow.
I feel my fate in what I cannot fear.
I learn by going where I have to go.
We think by feeling. What is there to know?
I hear my being dance from ear to ear.
I wake to sleep, and take my waking slow.
Of those so close beside me, which are you?
God bless the Ground! I shall walk softly there,
And learn by going where I have to go.
Light takes the Tree; but who can tell us how?
The lowly worm climbs up a winding stair;
I wake to sleep, and take my waking slow.
Great Nature has another thing to do
To you and me, so take the lively air,
And, lovely, learn by going where to go.
This shaking keeps me steady. I should know.
What falls away is always. And is near.
I wake to sleep, and take my waking slow.
I learn by going where I have to go.
 

So...what favorite/treasured poem are you going to share for others reading this?

Monday, May 30, 2011

Michael Moorcock, Gloriana

Originally posted in September 2010 at SFF Masterworks.

 Even after four centuries, the Elizabethan Age still carries magical memories for Anglo-Americans.  It was the age of Spenser (The Faerie Queene), Shakespeare (among others, A Midsummer Night's Dream), and Sidney (Astrophel and Stella).  In fact, it was Spenser's The Faerie Queene that gave Elizabeth I her nickname of Gloriana and it is Spenser's mixture of fairy tales, intrigue, and the golden age of the English Renaissance that has strongly influenced Michael Moorcock's 1978 novel, Gloriana; or the Unfulfill'd Queen.

Originally published in 1978 and revised in 2004, Gloriana perhaps may best be considered as a novel that was written to be a sort of dialogue with Spenser's epic poem.  Both Spenser and Moorcock present idealized forms of Queen Elizabeth I, but whereas Spenser's work primarily reads as a paean to the peace and prosperity of 1590s England, Moorcock's work is much more complex, both with its titular character and with its depiction of life in an alt-world Earth.

Gloriana opens with the Queen Gloriana ruling the vast empire of Albion, which stretches across most of Eurasia and is now expanding into the newly-discovered lands of Virginia, named after her.  Despite having had several lovers and illegitimate children, she is, like the real Queen Elizabeth I, unmarried and it is this and the matter of controlling her vast empire around which the action of the novel revolves.  The ruler of Arabia wants Gloriana to become his, so he in turn can plunge that pacific realm into a cleansing bout of war and destruction.  A courtier of his solicits the aid of Captain Arturus Quire to help him subvert Gloriana to this end.  Quire in turn is locked in a political battle with the old councilor Montfallcon, who had earlier served Gloriana's father Hern and who seeks to preserve her from becoming the despotic ruler Hern had become by the end of his reign.

Although at first glance the central plot seems to be that of political machinations, Gloriana is much more than the summation of its plot.  Moorcock here perhaps has written his best prose, with Quire in particular standing out.  Some readers familiar with Mervyn Peake's villainous Steerpike (Moorcock did dedicate this novel to the late Peake and his wife Maeve, both of whom Moorcock had befriended in his youth) will see traces of that ambitious character and his thirst for power and prestige in how Quire comports himself around Gloriana's other courtiers, especially Montfallcon.  But there is another trait in common with Peake's Gormenghast novels, that of utilizing atmospheric effects to intensify what is occurring in several important scenes.  Passages such as the one below, taken from Quire's first meeting with the Arabian courtier, are representative of how Moorcock imbues his scenes with vivid descriptions:


Quire nods.  He clears his throat.  Along the gallery now comes a scrawny, snag-tooth villain wearing leggings of rabbit fur, a torn quilted doublet, a horsehide cap pulled down about his ears.  He wears a sword from the guard of which some of the rust has been inexpertly scratched.  His gait is unsteady not so much form drink as, it would seem, from some natural indisposition.  His skin is blue, showing that he has just come in from the night, but his eyes burn.  "Captain Quire?"  It is as if he has been summoned, as if he anticipates some epiurean wickedness. (p. 18)

It is this combination of memorable description with intriguing characters such as the aforementioned Quire and Montfallcon, among others, that make Gloriana a gripping novel.  However, there is much more to this novel than just memorable characters and detailed, interesting descriptions.  It is Gloriana herself and her um, "interesting" situation that makes this novel worthy of debate thirty-two years after its initial publication.  Moorcock is not content to have Gloriana reign contentedly over her vast, peaceful realm.  Rather, he introduces questions of sexual politics to this story that are controversial for many.  Gloriana has a sexual dysfunction; she cannot orgasm, no matter how hard she tries with both clandestine lovers and with inanimate objects.  This sexual dysfunction plays a major role in the book, as it is the flaw through which Quire manages to arrange his machinations and against which Montfallcon rails, increasingly strident, throughout the novel.  The original ending (printed as an "alternate" Ch. 34 in my 2004 edition) is very disturbing for some, who saw it as a glorification of a heinous act, while Moorcock insists that it is more symbolic of a larger issue of sexualization of Self and of Gloriana's politics around which the novel revolves.  It certainly is a provocative scene, one that forces the reader to reconsider what she may have thought the novel to be about, but it certainly does not make it easy for the reviewer to discuss without straying from the realm of reviewing and into the world of literary critique.  Speaking solely for myself, the revised scene works better, as it clarifies Moorcock's intents without lessening the shocking realization contained within that concluding chapter.

Gloriana is much more than a simple fairy-tale rendition of an idealized Queen Elizabeth I and her court and world.  It is a well-written, engaging tale that will remind some readers of Mervyn Peake's Gormenghast.  Quire, Montfallcon, and Gloriana's characters are vivid, well-drawn, and they serve to drive the novel forward at a quick yet not too rapid pace.  Gloriana is much more than what it appears on the surface, as Moorcock's exploration of sexual politics and how intimately connected a ruler's personality can be with his/her realm make this a novel that will linger in the reader's thoughts long after the book is closed.  It is not without its controversies, as certain events could easily be read as a glorification of certain atrocities; ironic, considering the efforts Moorcock has done to combat those interpretations of the novel.  It certainly is one of Moorcock's best-written efforts and its depth is much greater than the norm for novels of this sort.  Gloriana is a "masterwork" in its prose, characterization, and thematic content and it will continue to be a moving work decades from now.
 
Add to Technorati Favorites